Concept of Bail

In the context of India, individuals who have been detained often express a primary interest in understanding the bail process. The Indian bail system aims to achieve a harmonious equilibrium between two core concepts pertaining to the human rights of the accused individual: the entitlement to personal liberty and the societal interest, while also ensuring the presence of the accused in court for the purpose of facing legal proceedings. This blog post delineates distinct categories of bail and pertinent legal precedents associated with each.

Introduction

Bail is the release of a suspect from jail pending trial on the condition that he or she will appear in court on the date and time set by the judge. In the context of India, a broad differentiation exists between offences that are eligible for bail and those that are not. The Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) delineates criminal procedure regulations. 

Under the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code, an accused individual may be granted bail by either a police officer or a court magistrate. Bail may be issued to a defendant in order to secure their presence in court and protect their liberty throughout the period leading up to the trial. Bail is typically awarded on the condition that the accused individual pledges to appear at scheduled court proceedings. Without sufficient guarantees, the accused individual may be detained in custody until their trial. The notion of bail is a legal mechanism that enables an individual who has been accused of a crime to be granted release from detention before their trial takes place. The legal provisions pertaining to bail in India are predominantly established within the framework of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) and the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Nevertheless, the comprehension and implementation of these laws have been subjected to a multitude of legal precedents, including those established by the Supreme Court of India and the various High Courts throughout the nation.

Hussainaira Khatoon v. State of Bihar, The prominent legal case pertaining to Bail in India examined the matter of prolonged Bail proceedings and its extent under the purview of Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. This analysis aims to explore the various types of bail that can be presented by an individual facing charges in the Indian legal system. The verdict of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Dr. Kafeel Khan has attracted much attention in recent years. Dr. Khan, a medical professional specializing in the care of children, was apprehended and detained under the National Security Act (NSA) on the grounds of purportedly delivering provocative oratory during demonstrations opposing the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) in the state of Uttar Pradesh. Notwithstanding the lower court's decision to grant bail, Dr. Khan's release from custody did not occur, and his detention was extended pursuant to the National Security Act (NSA). In its ruling, the Allahabad High Court made the observation that the granting of bail is typically the norm, whereas the imposition of imprisonment is considered an exceptional circumstance. The court ruled that the indefinite detention of an individual solely on the grounds of a potential future commission of a comparable offense is unlawful. The court additionally noted that the mere potentiality of an accused individual posing a risk to public order cannot serve as a valid justification for refusing to grant bail.

Types of Bail in India

Under Indian Penal Code (CrPC), there are 4 types of bail that an individual may apply based on the stage of the associated criminal case.

• 1.       Regular Bail (in Bailable and Non-Bailable offences).
• 2.      Anticipatory Bail.
• 3.     Interim Bail.
• 4.      Default Bail.

Regular Bail:

A person arrested and detained in police custody may apply for and get standard bail. Under Sections 437 and 439 of the Criminal Procedure Code, an individual may apply for regular bail.  There are two distinct categories of bail for regular offences.

• Bail for Typical Bailable Offences

The procedure for acquiring bail in cases that are eligible for bail is delineated in Section 436 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The accused individual possesses the lawful entitlement to secure their release through the provision of bail. Police officers are legally obligated to provide bail when requested by an individual. Furthermore, it delineates the maximum term for pretrial custody. The Court may release the accused on bail, with or without sureties, if their detention while the investigation exceeds half of the maximum term of imprisonment for the alleged offence.

• Justifications for Releasing Jailed Suspects

To move forward with the bail application process, the accused must meet the following requirements:

• The accused is given the benefit of the doubt regarding guilt (they may be innocent).
• Verification of their participation in the crime requires an investigation.
• There is no need for a ten-year prison sentence, incarceration, or execution because the crime is minor.

Customary Bail for Inadmissible Crimes

The trial court and the Magistrate before whom the police present the defendant have the authority under Section 437 to decide whether or not to issue Bail. However, the following circumstances may result in bail being granted for a non-bailable offence:

• If the Accused Person's Age Is 16 Or Less;
• When a female suspect is involved,
• Illness or infirmity of the Accused
• Only in exceptional circumstances is bail set for repeat offenders.

According to Section 437 (1), the only person authorized to release an accused person is the official in charge of the case. The Magistrate will deny bail during the bail hearing if:

• There is sufficient evidence to conclude that the defendant committed a crime punishable by death, life in prison, or a term of seven years or more in jail;
• The individual has been convicted on two or more instances of a crime punishable by death, life in prison, or a sentence of seven years or more in jail;

Committing or conspiring to commit a serious crime  

Inmates released on Bail are subject to certain conditions, such as but not limited to:

• The defendant must appear in court as required by the bond agreement;
• The suspect shall refrain from committing any additional acts that are identical to those for which he is currently being investigated;
• The defendant must not try to prevent any witness or other person with knowledge of the case from testifying or from providing admissible evidence.

Anticipatory Bail:

Individuals who believe that they may face criminal charges for which bail would not be granted have the option to submit an application for anticipatory or advance bail per Section 438 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The High Court or Sessions Court in the jurisdiction where the purported offence occurred is the suitable forum for submitting the petition. The issuance of anticipatory bail under this provision serves to avert the apprehension of an individual by law enforcement authorities.

The Indian Supreme Court made it clear in the case Sushila Agarwal et al. v. State (NCT of Delhi) et al. that anticipatory bail lasts till the conclusion of the trial and is not limited in time.

Temporary bail or Interim Bail

The term "Interim Bail" is used to refer to the temporary release on bail. The defendant has been granted interim bail, which will be in effect until the regular or anticipatory bail hearing takes place. The time required for processing is the primary factor contributing to the delay in document provision from subordinate courts to the High Court. Nevertheless, the bail hearing is the stage at which the provisional bail is ultimately determined.

Default Bail

The concept of Default Bail refers to a unique form of bail procedure that differs from the aforementioned Bail processes. In instances where the police or investigating agency neglects to file their report or complaint within the designated timeframe, the offender may be granted default bail. According to section 57 of the Criminal Procedure Code, in cases when an arrest is conducted without a warrant, the duration for which the suspect can be detained should not exceed 24 hours. The inquiry must be concluded and the charge sheet must be filed within the designated 24-hour timeframe, as failure to do so will result in the accused being eligible for statutory or default bail as outlined in Section 167.

References 

1. https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-5053-types-of-bail-under-crpc.html

2. https://blog.ipleaders.in/bail-provisions-under-the-code-of-criminal-procedure/

3. https://articles.manupatra.com/article-details/HUSSAINARA-KHATOON-V-Home-Secretary-STATE-OF-BIHAR#:~:text=This%20landmark%20case%20emphasized%20upon,the%20procedure%20established%20by%20law%22.

Please follow  Atharv Law Services for Further Reading.