Introduction
Details of the offence or charges against an accused person are documented in a charge sheet compiled by the investigative agency or police. From the initial report of a crime (FIR) being filed to its conclusion (the final report is written and submitted), the whole investigation process is documented in this report. Criminal Process Code Section 173 [1] outlines the charging process.
Information such as whether an offence appears to have been committed, if the accused has been arrested, whether he has been released on bond, and whether he has been transferred to custody pursuant to Section 170 of the Criminal Procedure Code [2] are all included on the Charge Sheet. The charge sheet details the crimes for which the accused is being tried, allowing the prosecution to begin once it is filed with the court.
The High Court retains its inherent powers under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, allowing it to issue any order necessary to secure the ends of justice, give effect to any order issued under the Criminal Procedure Act, or prohibit the abuse of process of any court. To stop any criminal proceedings against the accused, the High Court's jurisdiction can be exercised. The court will consider the following while deciding whether to dismiss an indictment or charge sheet:
1. The court, in exercising its power under Section, must determine whether the allegations in the complaint or the charges created constitute the basic ingredients of a crime accused under the Indian Criminal Code or whether the charge sheet on its face does not make any offence.
2. When the trial court does not have the authority to hear the case, either because it lacks subject matter expertise or because the law prohibits it from doing so.
Case Law
Details of the offence or charges against an accused person are documented in a charge sheet compiled by the investigative agency or police. From the initial report of a crime (FIR) being filed to its conclusion (the final report is written and submitted), the whole investigation process is documented in this report. Criminal Process Code Section 173 [1] outlines the charging process.
Information such as whether an offence appears to have been committed, if the accused has been arrested, whether he has been released on bond, and whether he has been transferred to custody pursuant to Section 170 of the Criminal Procedure Code [2] are all included on the Charge Sheet. The charge sheet details the crimes for which the accused is being tried, allowing the prosecution to begin once it is filed with the court.
The High Court retains its inherent powers under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, allowing it to issue any order necessary to secure the ends of justice, give effect to any order issued under the Criminal Procedure Act, or prohibit the abuse of process of any court. To stop any criminal proceedings against the accused, the High Court's jurisdiction can be exercised. The court will consider the following while deciding whether to dismiss an indictment or charge sheet:
1. The court, in exercising its power under Section, must determine whether the allegations in the complaint or the charges created constitute the basic ingredients of a crime accused under the Indian Criminal Code or whether the charge sheet on its face does not make any offence.
2. When the trial court does not have the authority to hear the case, either because it lacks subject matter expertise or because the law prohibits it from doing so.
Case Law
The Supreme Court has elaborated on a number of additional reasons in a series of rulings, and we have included a selection of those rulings in full below.
The Supreme Court ruled in “Nagawwa v. V.S. Konjalgi, 1976 AIR 1947, 1976 SCR 123” that the order of a Magistrate issuing process against the accused can be quashed or set aside in the following situations: where the allegations made in the complaint or the statements of the witnesses recorded in support of the same, taken at their face value, make out absolutely no case against the accused; or where the complaint does not disclose the essential ingredients of an offence which is alleged again.
This paragraph restates the importance of justice and reminds litigants that they should not use the court system to take out their anger or vengeance on someone who may be completely innocent.
When deciding whether or not to dismiss a complaint or charge sheet, the courts use extreme caution and carefully consider all of the relevant factors.
In some cases, the Hon'ble Courts will not dismiss the charge sheet. Still, they will instead direct the Investigating Agencies to conduct the additional investigation or even direct the accused to file a discharge application with the court below. The accused may remain out on bail pending the outcome of these processes (this depends on the discretion of the trial court). The Hon'ble High Courts frequently issue orders requiring the trial court to hear bail hearings for defendants on the same day they file their requests.
Conclusion
A charge sheet is a legal document detailing allegations against a suspect in a criminal case. Details concerning the alleged offence, such as the date, time, place, and any other pertinent information, are included in this document, often generated by law enforcement or prosecuting authorities. The charge sheet is a legal document to formally accuse the defendant of a crime and launch the prosecution. Quashing of a charge sheet completely depends on the discretionary power of the Hon’ble Court.
The Supreme Court ruled in “Nagawwa v. V.S. Konjalgi, 1976 AIR 1947, 1976 SCR 123” that the order of a Magistrate issuing process against the accused can be quashed or set aside in the following situations: where the allegations made in the complaint or the statements of the witnesses recorded in support of the same, taken at their face value, make out absolutely no case against the accused; or where the complaint does not disclose the essential ingredients of an offence which is alleged again.
This paragraph restates the importance of justice and reminds litigants that they should not use the court system to take out their anger or vengeance on someone who may be completely innocent.
When deciding whether or not to dismiss a complaint or charge sheet, the courts use extreme caution and carefully consider all of the relevant factors.
In some cases, the Hon'ble Courts will not dismiss the charge sheet. Still, they will instead direct the Investigating Agencies to conduct the additional investigation or even direct the accused to file a discharge application with the court below. The accused may remain out on bail pending the outcome of these processes (this depends on the discretion of the trial court). The Hon'ble High Courts frequently issue orders requiring the trial court to hear bail hearings for defendants on the same day they file their requests.
Conclusion
A charge sheet is a legal document detailing allegations against a suspect in a criminal case. Details concerning the alleged offence, such as the date, time, place, and any other pertinent information, are included in this document, often generated by law enforcement or prosecuting authorities. The charge sheet is a legal document to formally accuse the defendant of a crime and launch the prosecution. Quashing of a charge sheet completely depends on the discretionary power of the Hon’ble Court.
For Further Reading, please follow Atharv Law Services
References
1. https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1412034/#:~:text=173.,be%20completed%20without%20unnecessary%20delay.
.png)
0 Comments
If you have any doubt, Please let me know.